Oreo Ice Cream Cake

Share to Facebook Share to Twitter Email This Pin This

Pin It

Today was my awesome cousin Austin's birthday. He's actually always seemed more like a nephew (or our own kid before we even had kids of our own) and we've watched him grow from this adorable, amazing, funny, sweet little boy into this adorable, amazing, funny, sweet young adult who STILL seems to enjoying hanging out w/ us for some reason! So, I asked him yesterday what his favorite kind of cake was and he replied "Ice cream cake!!!". During a stop to one of the local grocery stores, I checked out all the ice cream cakes they had in the freezer and not surprisingly at all, I found that there wasn't a single ice cream cake that my girls could eat since they were all "Made on shared equipment with peanuts and tree nuts." Boo.

Unfortunately, there aren't too many store-bought ice cream cakes that the girls can eat given that one's severely allergic to peanuts and the other's severely allergic to tree nuts. Dairy Queen has one but honestly, I've never been a huge fan of theirs. Though that layer of crunchies is good, I prefer more cake with my ice cream and not the other way around. We used to get them from Cold Stone (YUM!!) until my 'nut-free' birthday cake a few years back accidentally came with a layer of peanut butter in it!!!!! You can bet that I'm totally turned off by them now. Thank GOD Little Sis only took a teeny tiny bite of her piece and spit most of it out because she didn't like it. It wasn't until Big Sis started yelling "This has peanut butter in it!!" that we figured out why. We watched her like a hawk for about an hour but then it was bedtime. After a couple more hours of vigilant watching over her while she slept, she finally threw up an ungodly amount all over herself but kept right on sleeping. Poor funny little thing. Luckily, I had put her down to sleep on a water-proof mattress cover on my bed and towels to cover the floor up which meant the clean up was quite manageable. And I thank my lucky stars that I awoke to an energetic Little Sis jumping up and down on the bed the next morning like nothing ever happened. Whew! 


I decided to just make my own. I've made them for the hubby in the past, before we ever had kiddies to worry about. I went with an Oreo Ice Cream Cake using my favorite cupcake recipe: Pastry Affair's Vanilla Cupcakes. I simply added about 16 coarsely chopped (like each cookie was cut into about 9 pieces) Double Stuffed Oreo Cookies to the batter and mixed well. Mmmmm. Oreos.

Here's the batter in a 8x8 or 9x9 baking dish. I don't know which but either would do. :)

And here's the cake, right out of the oven. This one took a while to bake - about 30 minutes. You should definitely keep a watchful eye out on yours at around the 25 min mark. Mine got a little browner than I would have liked, but the inside just wasn't cooking very quickly. I guess that's why it's called a CUPCAKE recipe. But this still turned out FABULOUSLY!

Ooops! I forgot to take pictures of the next step, but I let the cake cool in the baking dish for a few minutes then loosen the edges with a knife and carefully flip it out onto a plate (upside down) and let cool COMPLETELY. Then, cut the cake in half, laterally and placed the top half onto a separate plate.

Next I emptied the ice cream out onto a cutting board and sliced it evenly into thirds. My ice cream carton wasn't full, but I still had plenty.

I placed the 1st third of ice cream onto one corner of the cake and then cut the other pieces of ice cream to fit accordingly. I even had some ice cream left over.

Then I re-placed the 'top' (which is actually the orginal bottom of the cake) on top of the ice cream layer.

I frosted the cake w/ my favorite frosting. It took me exactly one standard sized tub of frosting to ice this cake. After frosting it, I just stuck it in the freezer for a couple hours and it was ready to decorate and eat!

VOILA! A peanut/tree-nut free ice cream cake for the whole family to enjoy. And enjoy we did. It was seriously one of the yummiest ice cream cakes I've ever had, if I do say so myself and almost put the birthday boy into a food coma! lol. :)

Pin It

Happy Birthday, Geeeeeeeeno (nickname! Can't believe you are 19! Thank you so much for spending your special day with us and these girls that love your and your little sis SOOOOOOOOOOOO much! :) And Happy Early Birthday, Jenpalalalala!! Sorry I can't make you a cake on your birthday 2 days from now!

And if you LOVE all things Oreo, then you gotta check these out up close: Vanilla Oreo Cupcakes

Thanks so much for stopping by and please feel free to make my day by leaving me a comment, joining my blog in the top right corner or liking my on Facebook at MyEpicureanAdventures - the more the merrier! :)

Christine, aka happyvballgirl :)

This post has been shared at:
Who Needs a Cape?  Linky The Chicken Chick Anyonita Nibbles  HungryLittleGirl PIN MEme


Heather said...

Oh my this looks delicious! And I never would have thought to cut the ice cream and place on the cake...I always wait until it softens and then attempt to spread it...it isn't pretty! I would love for you to share this at what i am eating http://www.townsend-house.com/2013/07/what-i-am-eating-35.html

Kathy said...

Great post and the cake looks awesome!

Dana DeVolk said...

Woah, this looks amazing!! We are hosting an extra special month long linky party through all of July focusing on frozen Summertime treats and we would love for you to join us! The best part is there is also an amazing GIVEAWAY! To get in on the action please visit us at We Scream for Ice Cream Linky Party + GIVEAWAY! Live from July 1st until July 30th. Hosted by: Dana @ This Silly Girl's Life & Parrish @ Life with the Crust Cut Off We hope to see you there!

Rina @ Bento School Lunches said...

Looks SO delicious and not too complicated for me to give it a try! We are ice cream cake lovers :)

Tiffany Azure said...

MMMMM Looks yummy! Visiting from Tasty Tuesday, thanks for sharing!!

Tiffany Azure said...


Kim Vealey said...

I love it...if you're going to have cake and ice cream on your birthday, why not all in one like this? Pinning and stopping in from Tasty Tuedays, have a great day Christine!
Kim @ *Soliloquy Of Food & Such*

Cathy Compeau said...

Great post! I'm hoping you will share.....

I would love for you to share and link up at my weekly TGIF Link Party if you haven't already this week. Your favorite posts, most popular, recent or new! The party is open every Thursday night and closes Wednesday's at midnight. Followed by (Not SO) Wordless Wednesday! http://apeekintomyparadise.blogspot.com/. I would be honored if you join us! Have a wonderful week!

Hugs, Cathy

Jenn Christ said...

Oh yum this looks so good!!! What an excellent birthday cake to get :D

Shelley Robertson said...

Oh yum yum yummy!! I want to make this like right now... :) Thank you for sharing at Party In Polka Dots!!!!!!


Kim M said...

Oh boy, this looks yummy and easy enough for even me to make! :)

anyonita green said...

WHOA! What a clever idea! :) I rememebr asking my mom to make me an ice cream cake one day when I was around 11 or 12 and she said: "Can't be done. You need a machine for that." LOL. IN her defense, desserts aren't her forte, but all this time I was just taking her response at face value, writing off ice cream cakes as being the work of some clever manipulation! You've spelled it out so clearly; I've GOT to try this! Thank you so much for linking up with me this week at Tasty Tuesdays! I’ve pinned this & shared it with my followers! Please be sure to stop back by the party and check out some of the other links!

Diana - FreeStyleMama said...

The cake looks so yummy! Lovely family photo!

Kathy Penney said...

What a cool dessert! (No pun intended.) I love cookies and cream ice cream so I would love to try this. And what a great way to celebrate as a family! Thanks for sharing at All Things Pretty!